College students walk along a sunny, tree-lined campus sidewalk and roadway surrounding a large, mature tree trunk in a mulch bed next to a white clapboard building.
This past summer, after a thorough risk assessment, the landscape crew decided it was necessary to remove a beloved elm tree on Hepburn Road.
A historic sepia tone photo shows a large building column to the left and campus sidewalks and buildings ahead with a large tree to the left.
The large Hillcrest elm, shown on the left side of this photo from the late 1930s, has been a fixture on campus for many generations of Middlebury students. (Credit: Middlebury Special Collections )
A section of an old elm tree standing on green grass reveals a hollow interior.
A limb from the old elm tree on Hillcrest reveals a hollowed out interior, which made the tree dangerously unstable for a pedestrian area. (Credit: Tim Parsons )
Three college students use long-handled shovels to dig a large hole in a grassy campus lawn in front of a white clapboard building.
“I was taught by Lily Carone, the landscape curator for the Smith College arboretum, that maintaining old trees involves dealing with loss, and the only way us arborists can accept loss is to plant new trees. We plant trees every year, some years planting up to two trees for every one removed.” —Tim Parsons  (Credit: Brett Simison )
A man in a green fleece jacket and a young man in a blue fleece pullover work together to position and straighten a young tree inside a deep hole on a grassy lawn, while a small group of students and staff watch.
“With over 2,400 trees we manage, an occasional removal is never surprising. The loss of the Hillcrest elm hit a nerve though, and multiple students had reached out to me wanting to honor the old tree. Even being the first evening of fall break, I was so happy to see many students, faculty, and staff come and help plant the replacement.” —Tim Parsons  (Credit: Brett Simison )
A man in a green fleece jacket and a person in a striped sweater crouch over a newly planted sapling in a dirt hole to remove burlap and wire caging from its root ball using bolt cutters, while several onlookers watch from the grass behind them.
“What we don’t see in these pictures is the rest of the celebration. We’d teamed up with Environmental Affairs and the Climate Action Program for this, and we’re celebrating our 16th year of being a certified Tree Campus by the Arbor Day Foundation. I brought the tools, but the important part (cider and donuts!) they graciously provided.” —Tim Parsons  (Credit: Brett Simison )
A man in a green fleece jacket and tan cap holds a rectangular stone engraved with the year "1860" in the foreground, while two students lean on shovels in the grass behind him.
“I’ll probably get into trouble for this, but I’m declaring the new elm the Class of 1860 tree. After being hit by lightning in 2006, the previous 1860 tree was removed. Imagine being in the Class of 1860 (with Joseph Battell!). You’re not sure if you’re going to war—heck, you may not even have a recognizable country in five years. But they had hope, and I know because they planted a tree. Not for them, but for us. So, we too are planting a tree, because we have faith and hope in the Middlebury mission, and we’ll carry the hope of 1860 forward for the next 165-plus years.” —Tim Parsons  (Credit: Brett Simison )